How hard should I make my Escape Rooms?

First: there is no official ranking. If you write to us I want the difficulty of my room to be 4.5 it doesn’t mean absolutely anything. Out of 5, 10, 100 or?
Same as all the beginner, novice, intermediate, expert and master names businesses come up with for their games.
Lets take it one step at a time.
Success rate
This has nothing to do with the quality of the game. Actually many games bragging to have very low success rate proved to be close to impossible to solve or just not well thought AKA illogical.

The easiest way, if you want to go down this doomed path without putting illogical steps, is to either put a few really really really smart games for players to spend a lot of time on OR by just putting an overall great number of quality games to slow down even the fastest and most experienced players.
Optimal timing
This is what you really want. A game that is good regardless of how many players you have in your rooms. Taking the boring 1 hour standard most escape room businesses worldwide have chosen, you would aspire to have winning teams exiting between the 50th minute and the 60th of course.
People almost never come back to play the same game!
Good business practice: time is up. Game master enters the room and shows the game till the end to prove them all was logical and possible to finish.
Making a room impossible to finish is either poor design or a pretty unethical approach this business.
Optimal success rate
What really happens when you have 3 games and you put 3 different random labels on them: Easy, Medium and Hard. Nobody, or not to be too extreme, very few people would ever want to play Easy. Even if its their first time ever doing something. People always think they are better and smarter than what they are.
Your first time clients who play Hard will most likely never return: if they win they will think they are passed that grade and if they loose… well, yes it was hard but I was close. Psychological factor: I played hard, I cant downgrade now.
Also if the thematic of a Harder game is more appealing than any easier, you just blew your chances to see return business.
Of course I am talking of places were many games are established on the market, not in a location with only you and your worse off few competitors.
What you need is equality withing the rooms: your key-phrase should be: all games are equally challenging although they use various combination of very different puzzles and logical thinking.
To put it simply
Players want to have fun, it is entertainment they are after and lots of enthusiasts put their heart in it. Nobody wants to pay to feel stupid so why not train your staff to let most teams win, a hard and deserved win of course, and see them leave with a smile.
For customer satisfaction: games must be good and challenging, an easy win is unsatisfying and often worse than a fair defeat. There is a thin line never to cross between being a pushy game master in good faith and an actual support with minimum interference and break of atmosphere and ambiance.
Serve all the games you have as an independent and incomparable experience.

How to achieve Optimal timing and Success rate? Ask us at info@buyescapegames.com
Previous article about Escape Room difficulty levels.